Gmp
GreenMedical Packing
Back to NewsTechnical Insights

Alu-Alu vs PVC/PVDC Blister: Choosing a Barrier Format for Moisture-Sensitive Tablets

By the Green Medical Packing engineering team

Alu-Alu vs PVC/PVDC Blister: Choosing a Barrier Format for Moisture-Sensitive Tablets

Two formats, two mechanisms

Both formats protect a tablet from moisture, and both are sold as high barrier. The difference is where the barrier comes from.

A thermoformed blister forms the cavity from a plastic film, either rigid PVC or PVC coated with PVDC. The plastic carries the mechanical shape and the coating carries most of the moisture resistance. A cold-form blister instead builds the cavity from a laminate in which an aluminium layer does the barrier work, with a plastic film on either side for formability and sealability.

That single difference decides almost everything else: the barrier level, the machine, the tooling, the cavitation possible per stroke and the way the pack is costed.

Barrier: what the numbers look like

Water vapour transmission rate is measured on flat material, usually at 38 °C and 90 % relative humidity. Indicative ranges are shown below. Confirm them against the supplier's own test report for the exact grade, because coating weight and film gauge move the number considerably.

FormatIndicative WVTR (g/m2/day, 38 °C / 90 % RH)What drives the value
Rigid PVC, 250–300 µmroughly 1.5–2.5Film gauge and formulation
PVC/PVDC, 40 g/m2 coatingroughly 0.3–0.8Coating weight and coating integrity
PVC/PVDC, 60–90 g/m2 coatingroughly 0.1–0.3Coating weight, drying and adhesion
Cold-form alu-alu laminatebelow 0.01 with an intact foil layerFoil gauge, pinholes, forming depth

Two practical notes follow from that table.

First, a formed cavity transmits more than the flat sample, because the material is stretched at the corners. The deeper the pocket in relation to its width, the larger that increase. Data from a flat sheet is a starting point, not the pack's performance.

Second, alu-alu barrier depends on foil continuity. A pinhole from forming, or a crease at a corner, is a leak path that no laminate specification prevents on its own.

Machine and tooling implications

Thermoformed formats run on standard blister machines: the film is heated, formed with a plug or air assist, filled and sealed. Tooling is comparatively modest, and changeover between formats is routine.

Cold-form material needs a press capable of forming the aluminium laminate at room temperature, usually at higher tonnage and slower cycle time. The forming dies are specific to the pocket geometry, and the forming window is narrow: too little pressure leaves incomplete corners, too much thins the foil and starts pinholes.

Before a switch, three machine questions decide feasibility:

  • Can the press reach the tonnage the pocket needs, at the cavitation you want?
  • Is the forming die available for the pocket geometry, or does it have to be made?
  • Does the line speed match the product plan, given the longer cold-form cycle?

Where each format fits

Product situationThermoformed PVC/PVDCCold-form alu-alu
Standard tablets, 12–24 month shelf life, moderate humidityUsual choiceMore barrier than needed
Hygroscopic or effervescent-type productsViable at higher coating weightsCommon choice
Deep pockets relative to widthForming limits appear earlyDesigned for deeper draws
High cavitation on a fast lineHigher output per strokeLower output, higher tooling
PVC-free pack requirementNeeds a different base filmSuits the requirement naturally
Visual inspection of the tabletTransparent cavityOpaque cavity

The decision is rarely settled by barrier alone. A product that needs 0.05 g/m2/day and a 36-month shelf life pushes toward foil; a product with a 24-month claim and moderate sensitivity usually does not justify the tooling and cycle cost of cold form.

Cost structure: what changes when you switch

Material price per kilogram is the number buyers compare, but it is the smallest part of the difference. The larger movements are:

  • Tooling: a cold-form forming die for a new pocket geometry is a one-off cost that thermoforming may not need.
  • Output: cold-form cycles are slower, so the cost per blister rises even when material price is similar.
  • Cavitation: fewer cavities per stroke changes the per-unit economics, not just the hourly rate.
  • Scrap: forming-window losses and start-up waste are higher on cold form.
  • Secondary packaging: because the cavity is opaque, carton and leaflet artwork often change as well.

A realistic comparison uses cost per thousand packs, including tooling amortisation at the actual annual volume, not price per kilogram.

The PVC-free question

Where a market, retailer or internal policy requires a PVC-free pack, cold-form alu-alu answers it structurally, and coated PVC does not: a PVDC coating reduces transmission but does not remove the PVC base film. Claim wording still has to match the documentation, which is covered in PVC-free and recycled-content claims: what the paperwork has to show.

Switching formats: the specification items that change

1. Cavity film or laminate, with gauge or foil thickness and the forming depth it supports. 2. Lidding foil, since the seal lacquer has to match the new cavity material rather than the old one. 3. Seal parameters, because the sealing window differs between a coated PVC surface and an aluminium laminate surface. 4. Tooling drawing and pocket geometry, agreed before the first forming trial. 5. Stability protocol, since a format change is a packaging change for regulatory purposes in most markets. 6. Artwork, if the cavity is no longer transparent. 7. Line trial plan with acceptance criteria agreed in advance.

Seal strength limits for the new pair are worth fixing before the trial rather than after; the peel and burst figures that apply are set out in blister seal strength testing: peel and burst limits.

Three questions buyers ask

Is alu-alu always better for moisture? It transmits less water vapour when the foil layer is intact, but the formed pocket and the seal decide the result. A poorly formed alu-alu cavity can leak more than a well-formed coated PVC one.

Can the same machine run both formats? Sometimes. The press has to reach the tonnage the cold-form pocket needs, and the forming die has to exist for that geometry. Thermoform-only lines cannot switch without equipment.

Does a format change need new stability data? In most regulated markets a change of cavity material or format is a packaging change and requires stability support. Confirm the scope with the responsible regulatory team before the trial, not after.

Next step

Send the pocket drawing, the tablet dimensions and the target shelf life, and our engineers will compare the two formats on barrier, tooling and cost per thousand packs. Material options are listed under cold-form aluminium without PVC, standard blister PVC and high-barrier PVC, and lidding options under PTP aluminium foil. Broader format comparisons sit in our technical articles, including strip packaging vs blister for unit-dose solids.

Have questions about this topic?

Send your pack format and target market — our technical team replies within 48 hours.

Ask the technical team